It seems that custom domains do not 1. remember that you're signed in correctly and 2. fail to sign in you when signing in with OpenID.
I've experienced this problem for a long time. In the meanwhile, I've had to sign in using my email and password, even though I can successfully sign in to *.pbwiki.com wikis with my OpenID. Perhaps you should enable OAuth for custom domain wikis and just run all accounts through PBWiki.com, the way Satisfaction does?
Reply to this problem