Loading Profile...
Line breaks in PBwiki comments
When users comment on pages in PBwiki, the comments show up as one big block of text (no line breaks). Adding html to force line-breaks doesn't help either. Is it possible to change the formatting of the comments so that I can use line-breaks?
I’m thankful to find a good place to ask this question
1 person has this question
I have this question, too!
Tell me when someone answers.
The more people who ask this question, the more it gets noticed.
The more people who ask this question, the more it gets noticed.
-
Inappropriate?No. They deliberately strip all formatting from the comments. There is no way to turn that "off".
1 person says
this answers the question
-
Inappropriate?Owww, that's too bad. Thank you for the reply. I saw that in 2.0 line breaks show up properly. So I hope we'll get to upgrade our wiki soon.
I’m sad
-
Inappropriate?Yeah, it's a small tweak to make V1.0 not remove line breaks; by not fixing it (or anything else) in V1.0, they hope to force users to upgrade to V2.0.
-
Inappropriate?Guy - I don't appreciate your accusation. It is absurd to suggest that we're intentionally keeping product quality low in order to force users to switch to 2.0.
I was directed to this thread by David, our CEO, who asked me, "If this is indeed a small fix, can it be made?".
I’m dissapointed
-
Inappropriate?Brian,
Let's say you were going to "keep product quality low". There are three ways you could approach that:
1) Break existing features
2) Stop adding new features
3) Stop fixing broken features
No one has suggested that you're breaking existing features; that would be absurd. But, PBwiki has publicly committed to the next two: no new features ("we probably won't be releasing any new features on 1.0") and no bug fixes ("we can't support old versions indefinitely."). PBwiki has also stated that there will be more more V1 wikis ("you will also not be able to create a new 1.0 wiki any longer") and that everyone will eventually move to V2 ("that will mean moving everyone to 2.0.").
So what PBwiki is doing (keeping quality low and forcing users to V2) is well documented. I understand that, as Director of Engineering, you personally are committed to producing a quality product. But if you believe that the connection between those two things has been lost on everyone at PBwiki, then I think you're being a little naive.
Now, how hard is it to stop stripping line breaks from comments? My naive guess is that it would involve removing two bytes ("\n") from the bit of code that strips out unwanted characters.
