Global Hotkeys & Minimize to Tray for Linux?
I asked this question just over a year ago (http://www.songbirdnest.com/node/2503), and several times since and I've never had it answered adequately. Will Songbird support Global Hotkeys for linux, or the ability to send Songbird to the tray?
27
people have this question
I have this question, too!
Tell me when someone answers.
The more people who ask this question, the more it gets noticed.
The more people who ask this question, the more it gets noticed.
-
Inappropriate?I too am wondering this. It is definitely possible, as Amarok does both - out of the box. Will this be on the roadmap at any point? I would be more willing to switch over if this were in place.
-
Inappropriate?If you just want to minimise to the system tray under Gnome or KDE you can use a third-party application like kdocker. It's nowhere near a complete solution (like amarok's system tray icon) but at least you can utilise the tray until (if) this issue gets sorted.
-
Inappropriate?The system tray I believe has been developed as an add on http://addons.songbirdnest.com/addon/173 but I have not tested this myself.
The global hot keys is definitely something we want to have working on all platforms. I believe this will be working for the next version if not sooner, latest being 1.0. Sorry for no exact times but we have a lot on our place and don't know where everything is going to fit. -
Inappropriate?I'm hoping for global hotkeys under OSX. In general though, you've done an awesome job :-)
I’m confident
-
Inappropriate?I'm very used to these two from Amarok and I can't switch until I can use them. Which sucks because Amarok is getting really slow with big libraries.
The hotkeys I use all the time are play/pause/stop, next/previous, ratings and show/hide window. The funny thing is that I don't even use Amarok's hotkey system (there were some bugs there), but Compiz's: since Amarok allows querying and setting state via dcop, I have scriptlets triggered by Compiz shortcuts to do what I need. The problem is that Songbird doesn't allow that.
(In fact I don't really need the minimize to tray trick; I just need a shortcut that makes the player window go away & return when needed. The tray icon would just be gravy.)
It would be really cool if Songbird allowed some control from scripts: dcop, dbus, even some sort of Python bindings would be enough if Songbird exposed enough of its internals. Writing a XPI extension is just too hard for some things.
I’m frustrated
-
Inappropriate?I think I can actually do the hiding part with just JavaScript, except that sbIGlobalHotkeys is not implemented in 1.0, apparently. And mucking around with custom XPCOM is a bit too much for me; it already took a while to figure out how to control the existing ones via JS.
In fact, if sbIGlobalHotkeys* were added, I could do pretty much everything I need (including ratings, maybe) with just JavaScript. (Although figuring out what to call is a bitch.)
(*: or, even better, something like dcop to control Songbird via scripts. There are plenty of ways of using global hotkeys, it's controlling uncooperative applications like Songbird that is the hard part.)
I’m anxious
-
I have a patch for Media Keys at http://bugzilla.songbirdnest.com/atta... on bug http://bugzilla.songbirdnest.com/show... But this requires compiling the program, hopefully I can figure out how to turn this into global keys for linux. -
Inappropriate?It would be fantastic if this happened, but given the length of time since this was originally asked I absolutely don't expect anything.
I’m skeptical
-
Inappropriate?This is the function that I've been looking for. If songbird has this. then I will switch from Amarok 100%..
I’m anxious
-
Inappropriate?I also long for global hotkeys for Songbird in osx. I use quicksilver to create make a hotkey for iTunes to pause and play the song, and I always accidentally hit it while I'm in Songbird but to no avail.
-
Inappropriate?I've given up on Songbird; it's clear the developers don't care to implement requested features, and its poor performance was getting to me. Here's wishing them luck with their product.
I’m indifferent
-
It is early in the life of songbird, and the developers are working on it every day, which means that features are being implemented. They are surely focusing on the ones that they think people need most right now. I don't use Songbird yet as my primary music player because it is missing some features, but I keep following it knowing that one day they will have more time to implement some smaller features like this that I miss. Performance increases are made with every release as well. I don't think it as that they "don't care" at all, they are just limited. -
Inappropriate?So there are no global hotkeys for songbird at all?
Today I've heard about songbird for the first time and I would like to move on it (because amarok doesn't fit good enough in my GNOME desktop), but if it doesn't support global hotkeys and wikilyrics, then I won't use it...
I’m confused
-
Inappropriate?Either that, or fixing Songbird's command line interface which is apparently broken. Running "songbird -pause" would supposedly pause Songbird. That way, you could set up your environment to run that command when you press a hotkey.
I’m frustrated
-
Inappropriate?Yes, please fix the command line hotkey bug! Then I guess packagers will sort the hotkeys out themselves, when it comes to Linux distribution. http://bugzilla.songbirdnest.com/show...
I’m unsure how hard a "segmentation fault" bug might be to find
-
Inappropriate?http://addons.songbirdnest.com/search...
That should be what you're looking for with regard to global hotkeys... if you have your hotkeys properly set up in your environment it will work (uses XF86AudioPlay, etc.).
-
Could you elaborate on the problem? What did you try, what are you running, etc.? -
Inappropriate?ASUS F80S + Ubuntu 9.04 + GNOME 2.26.1 + Songbird 1.2.0 + http://addons.songbirdnest.com/addon/... (MultimediaKeysFlip)
Multimedia keys work, but prev/next skips a song, e.g. next skips to the song after the next.
Still no minimize to tray support, though.
-
Леонид, помогите пожалуйста! У ASUS F80S с Ubuntu 9.04 на борту со звуком происходит кошмар (и не только у меня), он воспроизводится рывками.
Как вы решили данную проблему?
Loading Profile...







CHAMP


