Several users on Wikipedia are working on the article related to the album 30 Seconds to Mars, released in 2002. These users were looking for professional review sources when they found out that AllMusic published a review of the album at the time of its release, which is different from the current one. The review was written by Jason D. Taylor, who gave the album a rating of 4.5/5 stars as the archives of Metacritic prove (thanks to the Internet Archive). Then, in 2005, the review disappeared and AllMusic staff changed its rating from 4.5 to 2. Therefore the review didn't meet Wikipedia criteria since reviews that include only rating and no text review could not be used as a source. Around 2012, a text review was added, written by Jon O'Brien. The rating didn't change, but the review gives a positive impression. Now, since we don't know if the actual reviewer gives the album the current rating, that review could not be used on Wikipedia and users are working on its removal. I'm writing here because this needs to be clarified and it would be great if someone of the AllMusic staff could solve this issue. Thank you.