Begin credits don't match end credits

  • 1
  • Question
  • Updated 3 years ago
  • Answered
I was watching the first episode of Cleverman season 2 and unlike season 1 which had standard credits at the beginning and the rest of the cast after the show, season 2 has regular begin credits and then "credits in order of appearance" which are the complete credits and contains most of the credits at the beginning. However, for credited casts that don't appear, they aren't in the end credits. How do you handle this situation? Do you list the the credits starting from the beginning and ignore the duplication in at the end? Do you list the actors in the beginning credits as "credit only" but no order? I've never seen this situation in all my edits before.
Photo of Adrian

Adrian, Champion

  • 1646 Posts
  • 1983 Reply Likes

Posted 3 years ago

  • 1
Photo of Michelle

Michelle, Official Rep

  • 13273 Posts
  • 10644 Reply Likes
Hi Adrian -

When cast lists are split between the opening credits and end credits, the two sections should be treated as one long cast list that happens to be interrupted by the actual movie, so the order should start based on the first credits listed. 

When an individual is credited in both the beginning and end credits you should only list the credit once with the order number for the first credit, so yes, we will ignore the duplication, unless the individual is credited under another character name.

You can find additional information on our guide on Cast Orders here.
(Edited)
Photo of Adrian

Adrian, Champion

  • 1646 Posts
  • 1983 Reply Likes
There's a couple of things I'm unclear on. You say "When an individual is credited in both the beginning and end credits you should only list the credit once with the order number for the first credit". This is not true for films or even for TV shows that have credits in the order of appearance at the end of the show. Those credits are always listed in the end credits order. That seems to follow under "Acting credits are ordered according to the most comprehensive cast list (the one listing the most actors); in most cases, this will be the list appearing in the end credits."

In the case of the episode I'm asking about, the ending credits are the most comprehensive one (though it doesn't list all the actors in the beginning credits, mainly because they didn't appear. That's what brought me to the question as it seems that it doesn't fall perfectly into either case.
Photo of Adrian

Adrian, Champion

  • 1646 Posts
  • 1983 Reply Likes
So here are the actual credits. Opening credits are:

Hunter Page-Lochard
Rob Collins
Tasma Walton
Rarriwuy Hick
Rachael Blake
Jada Alberts
Clarence John Ryan (as Clarence Ryan)
Tony Briggs
Luke Ford
Tamala Shelton
Marcus Graham
Deborah Mailman
Frances O'Connor
Iain Glen

After the show it says "Cast in order of appearance"
Hunter Page-Lochard    Keon West
Marcus Graham             Stephen McIntyre
Iain Glen                        Jarrod Slade
Jada Alberts                   Nerida West
Tysan Towney                Djukara
Kamil Ellis                       Mungo
Tessa Rose                    Yani
Rarriwuy Hicks               Latani
Tamala Shelton              Alinta West
Clarence Ryan               Jari
Ali Kadim                        Young Hairy
Rupert Reid                   Chief of Staff
Hoa Xuande                   Advisor #1
Shiv Palekar                  Advisor #2
Rachael Blake               Marion Frith
Sarah Armanious           Lucia
Frances O'Connor         Charlotte Cleary           
Nicolas Hope                  Dr. Mitchell
Rob Collins                    Waruu
Luke Ford                      Tim Dolan
Deborah Mailman           Aunty Linda
Isaac Drandic                 Hairy
Nathan Wentzel             Dying Hairy
Andreas Lohmeyer        Young Broker #1
Chad Mathew Whitelaw Young Broker #2
Kasia Stelmach              Beautiful Woman
Tony Briggs                    Boondee/Trevor
Allen Huynh                    Everick
Mark Winter                    Hendricks
Warwick Sadler               Jeremy Joplin

So, you are saying that this should be the correct ordering of the cast:
Hunter Page-Lochard    Keon West
Rob Collins                    Waruu
Tasma Walton                Araluen (credit only)
Rarriwuy Hicks               Latani
Rachael Blake               Marion Frith
Jada Alberts                   Nerida West
Clarence John Ryan       Jari (as Clarence Ryan)
Tony Briggs                    Boondee/Trevor
Luke Ford                      Tim Dolan
Tamala Shelton              Alinta West
Marcus Graham             Stephen McIntyre
Deborah Mailman           Aunty Linda
Frances O'Connor         Charlotte Cleary           
Iain Glen                        Jarrod Slade
Tysan Towney                Djukara
Kamil Ellis                       Mungo
Tessa Rose                    Yani
Ali Kadim                        Young Hairy
Rupert Reid                   Chief of Staff
Hoa Xuande                   Advisor #1
Shiv Palekar                  Advisor #2
Sarah Armanious           Lucia
Nicolas Hope                  Dr. Mitchell
Isaac Drandic                 Hairy
Nathan Wentzel             Dying Hairy
Andreas Lohmeyer        Young Broker #1
Chad Mathew Whitelaw Young Broker #2
Kasia Stelmach              Beautiful Woman
Allen Huynh                    Everick
Mark Winter                    Hendricks
Warwick Sadler               Jeremy Joplin

So, the only person in the start credits not listed is Tasma Walton. If the cast list were complete, would we then order by the end credits (because that is going to be confusing for a show!)
(Edited)
Photo of Adrian

Adrian, Champion

  • 1646 Posts
  • 1983 Reply Likes
But that isn't really the case here, at least in my opinion. The end credits are the complete ones and are in credit order. However, there are credits at the beginning that are not duplicated. (for example, most BBC shows I watch have opening credits but all those credits are replicated at the end.). This seems unique in the fact that there are openly credits that aren't fully replicated in the cast order at the end of the episode. Regardless of how they get inputted it will cause confusion.

Edit: This is more like a movie listing where the cast list really isn't split but is given again at the end.  However, unlike other shows that I have seen where they give the credits at the end in order of appearance, there are additional credits at the beginning which are basically the season credits and would generally be as "credit only" because they do no appear in the episode (and hence why they aren't listed in the end credits).

Also, the reason I asked here is because I do not believe the guide actually covers this case. I've edited hundreds of shows now and this is the first credit list that I've seen like this.
(Edited)
Photo of Michelle

Michelle, Official Rep

  • 13273 Posts
  • 10644 Reply Likes
Hi Adrian -

Thanks for the additional details.  To clarify further, in the case for this particular episode we would go by the order of the end credits (as they are the full credits).   For cast members who are credited in the opening credits but not in the end credits (who were credited but not featured in the actual episode), should be listed with the attribute "credit only" and listed without a cast order number.

Often times you will see other television episodes where series regulars are credited in the opening credits and additional cast will be credited in the end credits, in this scenario we would list the credits in the order based on the opening credits followed by the end credits.
Photo of Michelle

Michelle, Official Rep

  • 13273 Posts
  • 10644 Reply Likes
You're welcome, and thanks for taking the time to correct the listing!  These kinds of TV credit scenarios can be a little complicated, so I'm happy to help clarify the policy.  Have a good weekend!
Photo of Adrian

Adrian, Champion

  • 1646 Posts
  • 1983 Reply Likes
Hi Michelle,

I put the update in (https://contribute.imdb.com/updates/update?load=170707-170919-376000). Part of it went through but it never fully updated to the way I listed the credits. I looked today (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt6015370/) and it is fully back to the way it was before I put my edit in. Can you take a look and see why it hasn't been implemented (or was reverted) and advise me what to do next?
Photo of Michelle

Michelle, Official Rep

  • 13273 Posts
  • 10644 Reply Likes
Hi Adrian -

I noted that there is another user contradicting the credit order, which is why the updates were reverted.  I have now manually adjusted the cast credit order for the episode "Revival" here, the change should be live on the site shortly.  I have also taken steps to ensure that the data is not reverted again.
(Edited)
Photo of Adrian

Adrian, Champion

  • 1646 Posts
  • 1983 Reply Likes
Thanks Michelle. I will go ahead and submit the edit for episode 1.2 It will be update 170710-191248-046200
Photo of Adrian

Adrian, Champion

  • 1646 Posts
  • 1983 Reply Likes
Hi Michelle,

I hate to harp on this, but it looks like both the cast and writers on "Revival" have once again reverted to the incorrect order. Is it possible to reach out to the other user and point him to these threads?