Challenging correction 181125-120725-247000
Le jeu de l'amour et du hasard (1967)
This is my second attempt at editing the information that Marivaux (notorious XVIIIth century French playwrite) is the author of the original play, not the writer of this TV show, by just adding the (play) attribute.
My comment:
Le jeu de l'amour et du hasard (1967)
This is my second attempt at editing the information that Marivaux (notorious XVIIIth century French playwrite) is the author of the original play, not the writer of this TV show, by just adding the (play) attribute.
My comment:
Please see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Game_of_Love_and_Chance This submission duplicates #171126-102019-302000 which was rejected
” ReasonNot enough evidence.
Your contribution has been declined.There was not enough evidence submitted with your contribution.
- 2901 Posts
- 4906 Reply Likes
Posted 2 years ago
- 2901 Posts
- 4906 Reply Likes
This reply was created from a merged topic originally titled Challenging #181125-112922-194000.
Challenging correction 181125-112922-194000
Bel-Ami Der Frauenheld von Paris
German adaptation of the famous French novel "Bel Ami", one among several, including American ones (e.g. see Bel Ami (2012))
It is my second attempt at changing the novel's author: it was not written by Emile Zola but by Guy de Maupassant.
I do not blame IMDb editors to be unfamiliar with European literature, but at least they should learn how to use Wikipedia or Internet.
My comment:
Challenging correction 181125-112922-194000
Bel-Ami Der Frauenheld von Paris
German adaptation of the famous French novel "Bel Ami", one among several, including American ones (e.g. see Bel Ami (2012))
It is my second attempt at changing the novel's author: it was not written by Emile Zola but by Guy de Maupassant.
I do not blame IMDb editors to be unfamiliar with European literature, but at least they should learn how to use Wikipedia or Internet.
My comment:
The original novel was written by Guy de Maupassant, not Emile Zola.
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bel_Ami
This correction was already submitted and rejected once as #170430-114204-371000
”
ReasonNot enough evidence. Your contribution has been declined.There was not enough evidence submitted with your contribution.
Joel, Official Rep
- 1222 Posts
- 1716 Reply Likes
Hey Vincent,
Thanks for your posts about these contributions.
Do you have any additional evidence aside from the two Wikipedia links for our editors to review? These aren't entirely reliable as they can be updated and modified at any point.
Once we have more information we can do our best to help out.
Joel
Thanks for your posts about these contributions.
Do you have any additional evidence aside from the two Wikipedia links for our editors to review? These aren't entirely reliable as they can be updated and modified at any point.
Once we have more information we can do our best to help out.
Joel
- 7435 Posts
- 9862 Reply Likes
Perhaps Vincent Fournols considers this stuff to be common knowledge.
- 2901 Posts
- 4906 Reply Likes
Come on, Joel... I am absolutely disappointed by your answer.
I sure do consider it as common knowledge in France, and as mentioned in my comment, I do not expect it from IMDb editors. But at least they could use their own reliable sources when it comes to world literature, starting with Google.
Google images
https://www.britannica.com/topic/Bel-Ami
https://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_noss?url=search-alias%3Dstripbooks-intl-ship&field-keywords=B...
Last but not least I am baffled at your considering Wikipedia not trustworthy, especially for that kind of topic.
I sure do consider it as common knowledge in France, and as mentioned in my comment, I do not expect it from IMDb editors. But at least they could use their own reliable sources when it comes to world literature, starting with Google.
Google images
https://www.britannica.com/topic/Bel-Ami
https://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_noss?url=search-alias%3Dstripbooks-intl-ship&field-keywords=B...
Last but not least I am baffled at your considering Wikipedia not trustworthy, especially for that kind of topic.
- 2901 Posts
- 4906 Reply Likes
I wanted to add that It is much easier to probe and assess an information in WP than IMDb, by far.
Col Needham, Official Rep
- 6866 Posts
- 4909 Reply Likes
There appears to be quite a bit of evidence in support of your correction on the poster on IMDb :-)
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt3327554/mediaviewer/rm1508922624
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt3327554/mediaviewer/rm1508922624
- 2901 Posts
- 4906 Reply Likes
I had not even spotted that!! :)
- 2901 Posts
- 4906 Reply Likes
The same goes for Marivaux writing plays in the XVIIIe century.
Am I also to provide further evidences?
Am I also to provide further evidences?
(Edited)
Col Needham, Official Rep
- 6866 Posts
- 4909 Reply Likes
Related Categories
-
Data Issues & Policy Discussions
- 30032 Conversations
- 4502 Followers




