delete undefined country AKAs

  • 1
  • Problem
  • Updated 5 months ago
Merged

This conversation has been merged. Please reference the main conversation: Undefined aka titles

So many titles have an AKA with an "unidentified" country (and no attribute). These invalid AKAs cannot be deleted by a contributor. You've acknowledged over many years that this is an error, an artifact from an old system or something, and that they need to be deleted, yet here we are again and again complaining and nothing changes, no fixes, no removals.

Why not write a BOT that scans system-wide and in two steps: 1) deletes all occurrences of AKAs with no country set, for which AKA title already exists with the country code set, 2) for all other occurrences of AKAs with no country set, where the AKA title is not duplicated, scan the page for the country of origin and change the country of the invalid AKA to it.

Doing this manually by each contributor is obviously a waste of time since it never works. You have an editing anomaly. If you try to set the country on such an AKA you get an error that this can't be done. Why the heck not? Instead, it tells you, delete the invalid AKA, and create a new one with the country (this is kind of "duh" since it is *impossible* for a contributor to create an AKA without setting the country, only your broken system can (and does obviously) do that).

So you choose deletion of the bogus AKA and create a new correct one. Problem is, while the new AKA is created fine, the deletion of the invalid AKA without a country is always REJECTED by your editors! So the problem never gets fixed. I've tried resubmitting the deletion request with many different explanations including quoting the error messages that tell you it can't be changed and you MUST delete it, but every request is still denied. This appears to be a problem with training and informing your editors of this long-standing problem.
Photo of GoodFlixGary

GoodFlixGary

  • 175 Posts
  • 152 Reply Likes

Posted 5 months ago

  • 1
Photo of GoodFlixGary

GoodFlixGary

  • 175 Posts
  • 152 Reply Likes
Here's one. Can anyone delete this manually for me?

200316-054134-314000
200316-055258-005000
200316-224218-714000
200317-084152-038000
Photo of GoodFlixGary

GoodFlixGary

  • 175 Posts
  • 152 Reply Likes
Here are a couple more:

200319-223531-430000 That one's pretty simple: the AKA is already listed with a country, so this one is a duplicate with the country undefined.

200319-224749-147000 This one has two: one that's a duplicate (with undefined country) of an AKA that has the country defined. The other was one I tried to set the country and it said I had to delete and add – so I did that and the add was accepted immediately but not the delete. Now it's just another duplicate undefined that needs to be deleted.

This conversation is no longer open for comments or replies.