I hereby request IMDb that these two Indian cinema related keyword be removed and made redundant.

  • 1
  • Question
  • Updated 3 months ago
  • Answered
https://www.imdb.com/search/keyword?keywords=indian-poliziottesco

https://www.imdb.com/search/keyword?keywords=bollywood-poliziottesco

"Poliziottesco" is a specifically Italian subgenre of police procedurals. Applying it to Indian crime thrillers does not work as they do not follow the template.
Photo of Hurdy Gurdy Man

Hurdy Gurdy Man

  • 21 Posts
  • 14 Reply Likes

Posted 4 months ago

  • 1
Photo of Joel

Joel, Employee

  • 901 Posts
  • 1051 Reply Likes
Hi there,

Thanks for your post.

We always welcome additions and corrections to the database. If you're aware of inaccurate information on our site, please let us know through the 'Edit page' button which listed at the bottom of every page on our website. 

From here, you can provide specific details as to the information you'd like updating and we'll take prompt measures to investigate your claim and fix any inaccuracies. 

We regret we're unable to apply corrections on behalf of our users - instead, these need to be contributed via the 'Edit page' forms on the site itself. This ensures the correction is properly formatted and delivered to the appropriate members of our data editing team! 

Our Help Site contains a very useful guide on how to contribute data to IMDb: 

  https://help.imdb.com/article/contribution/contribution-information/how-do-i-con... 

Thanks in advance for your help in keeping IMDb as accurate and up to date as possible, please don't hesitate to let us know if you experience any issues while contributing the update.

I hope this helps.

Joel 
Photo of Hurdy Gurdy Man

Hurdy Gurdy Man

  • 21 Posts
  • 14 Reply Likes
This is unhelpful in the extreme. So contributors are supposed to clean the mess someone else created? Well, if IMDb was paying us, we would -- but it is not!
Photo of MAthePA

MAthePA

  • 1784 Posts
  • 3028 Reply Likes
"Poliziottescohas its roots in Italian heist films, it was also strongly influenced by rough-edged American police thrillers of the late 1960s and early 1970s. This subgenre generally used political conflicts and violence for largely apolitical tension-building and cathartic or emotional purposes. The genre's protagonists often simultaneously displayed both right-wing and left-wing views, and protagonists were often working class while villains were often wealthy right-wing conservatives. 
Though poliziotteschi films have been viewed by some critics as condemning a "liberal" or "weak" judiciary system as ineffectual in its treatment of criminals, the genre also suggests a more general distrust of authority, whether left-wing or right-wing, by portraying right-wing law enforcement, politicians and businessmen as hopelessly corrupt and manipulative.

In addition to the above wiki-quotes: 
A movie genre can not be limited to a nation or a country specifics; cinematography tends to preserve no boundary demarcation. Sometimes a set of objective reasons may result in a limited classification, e.g. noir genre. Film noir period is generally regarded as extending from the early 1920s to the late 1950s; and nowadays we operate the Neo-noir subgenre. So, even if we'd have reasons to separate Poliziottesco to the 1960s-1970s, there is no good point to classify a new genre since it was invented earlier. This is why, as I think, there are some keywords suggested for IMDb to separate the specific plots of poliziottesco films, such as:
  • bollywood-poliziottesco
  • indian-poliziottesco
  • british-poliziottesco
  • canadian-poliziottesco
  • french-poliziottesco
  • german-poliziottesco
  • hong-kong-poliziottesco
  • japanese-poliziottesco
  • malaysian-poliziottesco
  • north-american-poliziottesco
  • spanish-poliziottesco
  • swedish-poliziottesco
  • taiwanese-poliziottesco
  • thai-poliziottesco
  • turkish-poliziottesco
and so on. All of them may be used for a specific search. May be there is no need to separate between "bollywood-" and "indian-poliziottesco"; if so, they should be merged to the benefit of latter one.
Photo of Hurdy Gurdy Man

Hurdy Gurdy Man

  • 21 Posts
  • 14 Reply Likes
Indian crime thrillers do not fit the poliziottesco mould at all. These films tend to be in the usual Indian cinema manner where many genres are blended together. An action scene may be immediately followed by a slapstick comedy sequence followed by a romantic song followed by a family drama scene. There is hardly anything there that befits the label.
(Edited)