I have submitted Genre additions in the past for Mae West films that have not been accepted, primarily to add either Music or Musical. So far as I'm concerned, if she sings in the film, it deserves at least a Music genre, because her singing is a reason for my wanting to watch the show. (I've read the definitions of these genres; I know that what I just said is not the definition.) 5 of her 12 films are already tagged as Musicals (none yet as Music), and I agree with those.
I've had very few rejections among my contributions. Those for Mae West were submitted in Oct/Nov 2017. Should I resubmit, or will listing them here suffice; if the answer is "resubmit", should the genre be Music or Musical?
Belle of the Nineties (1934)
171008-080552-039000 Musical (would be satisfied with Music)
171014-162521-207000 Music (tried a week later when Musical did not appear; would be satisfied with this genre)
the story is about a Lillian Russell-type gay-nineties songstress, and she performs 4 songs.
Klondike Annie (1936)
171014-162249-560000 Music (tried a week later; would be satisfied with this genre)
171110-041954-219000 Music, Drama (about a month later)
she plays a gay-nineties entertainer, performs 6 songs.
Every Day's a Holiday (1937)
171014-162200-366000 Music (again, tried a week later; would be satisfied with this genre)
she plays a gay-nineties grifter who uses songs as part of her grift. Louis Armstrong also performs in 2 songs (not noted on the Soundtracks page); she performs 5 songs.
There are 3 more films I haven't watched recently, but they have 0, 1, and 2 songs performed by her on the Soundtracks pages, so the absence of Music/al is more reasonable...if the Soundtracks pages are correct.
Thanks in advance.