My Chicago Fire" review was not accepted. "did not meet the guidelines." Which guidelines?

  • 1
  • Problem
  • Updated 2 months ago
  • Solved
 "Chicago Fire" (2012) {Sacred Ground (#8.1)} My review:  Even more serious errors than low smoke volume or facial hair on firefighters, falls in the consistently flawed depiction of Paramedics operating far, far outside EMS protocols. As a 30-year Paramedic myself, my partners and I find it continuously irritating that Chicago Fire's medics never contact their Base ER before advanced treatment; never file EMS reports; never indicate that when it comes to patient care, their true "boss" is not the fire department at all, but in fact is the county EMS system. And the idea that a young lady physician resident, who was dismissed from a physician program, would EVER qualify to work as a licensed Paramedic, just because she was a "doctor-in-training", is laughable. The typical MD would have literally no idea how to function in the field. Certainly this otherwise excellent program has medical consultants on set. It's a shame the directors don't bother listening to the pros.

Unfortunately, the review editiors do not say which guideline was in error, so I have no way to correct my submission. Would appreciate any guidance you can offer. Thanks.
Photo of Patric Paramedic

Patric Paramedic

  • 1 Post
  • 0 Reply Likes
  • confused

Posted 2 months ago

  • 1
Photo of cinephile

cinephile

  • 1197 Posts
  • 1534 Reply Likes
Review Guidelines

  • Profanity, obscenities, or spiteful remarks in either the body or header of your review. 
  • Time-sensitive material (i.e. mentions of events, promotional tours, seminars, lectures, etc.).
  • Avoid unannounced spoilers! Please don't reveal crucial plot elements, if you include spoilers without warning readers in advance, your review may be subject to removal. To label a spoiler make sure you check the 'contains spoilers' checkbox. Also, please never include spoilers in your review header as this is always visible.
  • Square brackets [ and ] are not allowed apart from when used to link names and titles
  • Phone numbers, mail addresses, URLs, email addresses, links to Twitter or Facebook pages etc.
  • Availability, price, or ordering/shipping information.
  • Advertising, promotions or solicitations of any kind
  • Writing in ALL-CAPS! Writing sentences in all-uppercase characters is considered "SHOUTING" and must be avoided.
  • Content in languages other than English
  • Do not include personal opinions on real life events or subject matter on which a film is based.

I'm not sure why your review has been declined, but it is possible that it was because of the last criteria:

Do not include personal opinions on real life events or subject matter on which a film is based.
You can also verify if the title of your review wasn't the problem.