Peter Saxon

  • 2
  • Question
  • Updated 3 years ago
  • Answered
The IMDb page for this writer, consisting of a biography item and a trivia item which are identical, is inaccurate. I tried to help by submitting a new Trivia item on July 22. It has been acknowledged by email but not processed. My new information was:
The pen-name "Peter Saxon" was used by writer, editor and publisher W. Howard Baker (1925-1991) on novels published in the Amalgamated Press's Sexton Blake thriller series, of which Baker became the editor in 1956. The writer Wilfred McNeilly (1921-1983) was never editor of the Sexton Blake series, although he wrote for it under his own name after 1961 and ghost-wrote some first drafts of Sexton Blake stories that eventually appeared under the "house" name Desmond Reid, and the names of W. Howard Baker, W. A. Ballinger, and Peter Saxon. The character Sexton Blake was created not by Wilfred McNeilly - as is also astonishingly claimed here - but in 1893 by Harry Blyth (as Hal Meredeth). In 1968 McNeilly became one of Baker's team of writers for the Guardians series of paperback horror novels which were published under the Peter Saxon pen-name. The Peter Saxon novel The Disorientated Man (1966), which was the basis of the movie Scream and Scream Again (1969), was written not by Wilfred McNeilly but by Stephen D. Frances (aka the original Hank Janson) and W. Howard Baker. The 1959 movie Murder at Site 3 was based on the W. Howard Baker Sexton Blake novel Crime Is My Business (1958), and again had nothing to do with Wilfred McNeilly. The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction says: "He [McNeilly] achieved some minor notoriety when he claimed in print to have written all the work published under the byline W. Howard Baker - actually McNeilly's editor on stories written for the Sexton Blake Library and for Press Editorial Syndicate - and various other Baker pseudonyms, a claim since disproved.".
Explanation: I worked as an editorial assistant to W. Howard Baker at the Fleetway House (Amalgamated Press) and therefore knew and handled the work of both Baker and McNeilly. 
Photo of Keith Chapman

Keith Chapman

  • 2 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
  • disappointed and frustrated

Posted 3 years ago

  • 2
Photo of Rebecca

Rebecca

  • 178 Posts
  • 49 Reply Likes
Hi Keith, 

I have had a look at your submission and it looks like it has been rejected due to it seeming more like a biography and less like a piece of trivia. If this belongs in the mini biography section please resubmit this to the correct category. If you believe this is accurate as a piece of trivia please try to re-write the trivia to be more short and concise. Trivia is considered to be facts, rather than a long description.
Photo of Keith Chapman

Keith Chapman

  • 2 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
Okay, Rebecca. It looks like IMDb is content with retaining a page on Peter Saxon which is almost total rubbish! I am trying to  correct the page as you suggest, but the submission process seems tortuous and time-consuming to say the least. There is no reward in it for me, other than that I hate seeing respected sites like IMDb spreading misinformation. If IMDb do not want to accept the necessary revisions, the least they can do is delete their whole Peter Saxon page.     
Photo of gromit82

gromit82, Champion

  • 7549 Posts
  • 9640 Reply Likes
Keith: If the information on the Peter Saxon bio page at http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0049005/bio is wrong, the solution is to submit a Correct or Delete for the incorrect item. Just adding another item with the correct information will not be enough, because then IMDb would have two contradictory items, one with the correct information and one with the incorrect information. IMDb doesn't want to have trivia items on a page criticizing other items on the same page by saying that something is "astonishingly claimed" in one of the other trivia items.

Also, the item you submitted above is probably too long to be a Trivia item anyway. It would be better off being submitted as a Biography.

I hope this helps.
(Edited)