I have noticed a rather weird tendency of photograph appearances either disappearing from the acting filmographies or receiving "(credit only)" treatment. I don't know whether some SAG-AFTRA standards are in play here, but I wonder whether cases in which photographs were actually made for the movie, as it is with Alfred Hitchcock in Lifeboat (1944) or Bruce Davison in Willard (2003) might still be listed. Technically, actors worked for a day showing up for a photo shoot (and in case of Hitchcock he was actually photographed twice for "before" and "after" photographs) which still should be listed (unlike the use of pre-existing photographs).
There are also borderline cases - Liza Minelli is now listed as "credit only" in The King of Comedy (1982), because she only appears in a cardboard cutout in the movie, but it might as well have been "scenes deleted", because she had actual scenes shot, which were eventually deleted and that is the main reason why she has a cast credit.
So what are the rules in cases like that, or should it be decided depending on case? I should say that I have a few acting credits which are actually photographs, but they were credited and specially comissioned for productions.
There are also borderline cases - Liza Minelli is now listed as "credit only" in The King of Comedy (1982), because she only appears in a cardboard cutout in the movie, but it might as well have been "scenes deleted", because she had actual scenes shot, which were eventually deleted and that is the main reason why she has a cast credit.
So what are the rules in cases like that, or should it be decided depending on case? I should say that I have a few acting credits which are actually photographs, but they were credited and specially comissioned for productions.



Nikolay Yeriomin (Mykola Yeromin), Champion
In my humble opinion cases in which photographs were proven to be made for the film only might have been listed as exceptions, but it's just my opinion. Alternatively, people who modeled for photographs especially for the movie might be listed in "miscellaneous crew" (which is partially done as well, with photo doubles, additional voices, ADR etc.). The latter might probably be the best option as it won't bend the rules and will still give the person factual credit one might deserve.
Michelle, Official Rep
Thanks you for posting your suggestion here regarding edge cases for still photograph credits. I would encourage you to post a new Idea thread within the community with your comments about listing these credit types on the site, which will allow other users to vote and comment. Cheers!
Nikolay Yeriomin (Mykola Yeromin), Champion
Michelle, Official Rep
I see that you successfully re-posted the issue in a new thread, as the issue involves our policies the post has been modified to a problem and will be reviewed by our staff shortly. Cheers!
Nikolay Yeriomin (Mykola Yeromin), Champion