Shutting down the IMDb message boards is a terrible and small-minded decision.

  • 4
  • Problem
  • Updated 3 years ago
Merged

This conversation has been merged. Please reference the main conversation: IMDb message boards

Eliminating the IMDb message boards will make the IMDb.com site a dead zone of no better utility than a worn out, yellowed and insect-infested TV guide from 1982. Lively, interactive diverse commentary is the lifeblood of the site and removing it will tear the heart out of a website that has become a veritable internet institution. You should really rethink this rather shocking and backward decision if you are an individual who is party to the message boards' imminent destruction. Social media is the modern alternative you espouse as a replacement, but like many modern and supposedly "better" things, it just isn't fun, nor original, nor better. Think about the cool and fun places that were around when you were a kid but that have now been replaced by the sterile, the corporate, the bland and the ubiquitous. THAT is what you will be turning IMDb.com into if you go ahead with this wrongheaded and misguided "improvement". You will hence be known as the "no-fun" website that drove millions away from your erstwhile succe$$ful Internet Movie Database. I hope you will reconsider this decision and continue the success that the message boards have built for you all along these years, because your alternative is a downright dud. Thank you for reading.
Photo of Andrew B

Andrew B

  • 1 Post
  • 4 Reply Likes
  • Disappointed at the unjust decision to remove the IMDb message boards.

Posted 3 years ago

  • 4
Photo of Gabriel A Sica

Gabriel A Sica

  • 1 Post
  • 1 Reply Like
Andrew B. I agree with you MORE than wholeheartedly. What can Amazon possibly be thinking? They want to sell us their content, and then forbid us from exchanging our ideas on what they are making money from. I am seriously considering cancelling my Amazon Prime and switching to Hulu. What they are doing fits right in with Trump's Amerika.
Photo of Nobody

Nobody

  • 1455 Posts
  • 707 Reply Likes
I am seriously considering ... switching to Hulu.
FYI:

In 2014, Hulu did what IMDb is doing now.  They shut down their boards!!

In Hulu's early years, they had boards on all of their show and movie pages.
Those boards were great! ... By 2014 they'd got rid of those,
and then finally they shut down their general boards too.

Even now, Hulu still has a forgotten announcement from 2014,
saying "several teams" would be working for a "few months"
to develop a "new discussion platform" for Hulu.  ...
I'm not using Hulu anymore, so I don't know for sure,
but up to now I'm not aware that they ever completed that.

Sure, go ahead and switch to Hulu if you want, but know this:
Once upon a time, they too killed their own boards!!
Photo of Col Needham

Col Needham, Official Rep

  • 6866 Posts
  • 4909 Reply Likes
Separate sub-thread

Please reference the new conversation here: IMDb boards
Photo of Some guy

Some guy

  • 10 Posts
  • 28 Reply Likes
The message boards are what make IMDB a community -- they're the only truly interactive feature on the site.

Without the message boards, the only recognizably user-generated content left will be the same lame-ass reviews you can find anywhere online, but with less opportunity for interaction. (At least most OTHER review sites have comment sections!)

Without the message boards, IMDB will be nothing but a bone-dry catalog of the same basic movie stats available on Wikipedia and everywhere else, but less coherent, less informative, and immeasurably less interesting. Even the "External Links" feature will be just a reminder of the good stuff we should look at elsewhere.

I've been an active participant for 15 years, but without the message boards, I'm deleting my IMDB and Amazon accounts on the 20th and never looking back. After all, they need us more than we need them.
Photo of Morgan Sage

Morgan Sage

  • 11 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
This is like a bad dream.  So now I have to go to two sites, here for the basic information, and to Facebook for discussions that have always made my movie viewing a more clear experience.  I HATE Facebook (though I grudgingly use it to sign in to things).  And Twitter is just inane.

I've seen IMDB make bad decisions before (like trying to take away our painstakingly acquired movie lists, or make IMDB fancier and less user-friendly, but this is the worst yet.  They reversed the previous decisions when users objected.  Is there any hope they will reverse this one?

This conversation is no longer open for comments or replies.