Merging Witness and Witness Deluxe

  • 1
  • Problem
  • Updated 1 year ago
Katy Perry’s Witness (deluxe) was released some time ago which is great but the problem is that it LITERALLY replaced the standard edition. Thus, the standard edition can’t be scrobbled anymore.

The main issue I encountered is that any song I scrobble from Witness (deluxe) it’s registered as a different song from the the standard edition. Therefore, I have the same tracks appearing in my list twice. As a result, the experience becomes quite inaccurate. Chained to the rhythm, for instance, used to be my #1 top track before this happening...

I kindly suggest merging the two albums because the deluxe version has only 2 extra songs or... at least make the other songs scrobble as tracks from Witness (standard)
Photo of Gabriel Călin

Gabriel Călin

  • 4 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes

Posted 1 year ago

  • 1
Photo of Elliot Robinson

Elliot Robinson

  • 888 Posts
  • 2155 Reply Likes
The problem is you are looking at this purely from the perspective of a Spotify user, and that nobody else scrobbles using other streaming services, or - shock, horror - their own purchased mp3s and CDs. I, for example, almost never use Spotify, instead preferring to own my music.

While it's true the deluxe version seems to have replaced the standard edition on digital and streaming platforms, that doesn't mean the original standard version stopped existing. https://www.discogs.com/Katy-Perry-Witness/master/1193114

Deluxe versions and standards versions should never be merged, in my opinion - they are distinct releases. If they were the same thing, there'd be no such thing as a deluxe version. Aside from the differing tracklistings, deluxe versions frequently have distinct artwork, too.

I believe Last FM is aiming for some kind of aggregating feature for albums in the future, so that (to use this album as an example) there will be a "master" page for Witness, with listings for the variations as sub-pages. Don't quote me on that, though; it may be that it was merely a staff member agreeing it was a good idea when someone mentioned it elsewhere, rather than a statement of intent!

Last FM's primary purpose is surely accurate listening stats for users. As such, your suggestion seems to be driven by a desire for aesthetic tidiness rather than statistical accuracy, which is not really in step with Last FM's raison d'être.

Merging would be correct for things like "Witness (Deluxe) [Clean]", "Witness (Deluxe) [Explicit]", "Witness (Deluxe Edition)", and "Witness (Deluxe Version)".


Photo of Gabriel Călin

Gabriel Călin

  • 4 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
To be honest I thought merging albums will solve the issue with identical tracks being scrobbled as distinct entries. Seeing this from your point of view, I agree: merging albums is not a good option. Moreover, they solved the issue: now I can scrobble those tracks without having duplicates and also someone gave me the standard edition’s link. :D

On the other hand, I am sorry for my misunderstanding... I didn’t know you can scrobble using mp3s and CDs, but merely using streaming services.

Speaking of that, how can you scrobble if you use CDs or mp3s ?
Photo of Elliot Robinson

Elliot Robinson

  • 888 Posts
  • 2155 Reply Likes
Download the desktop scrobbler and use it with your media player of choice (iTunes, Windows Media Player, Winamp, etc).

https://www.last.fm/about/trackmymusic